Namespace without prefix in XML in R-CodePudding

In the XML package in R, it is possible to create a new xmlTree object with a namespace, e.g. using:

library(XML)
d = xmlTree("foo", namespaces = list(prefix = "url"))
d$doc()
# <?xml version="1.0"?>
# <foo xmlns:prefix="url"/>

How do I create a default namespace, without the prefix bar, such that it looks like the following?

# <?xml version="1.0"?>
# <foo xmlns="url"/>

The following does not produce what I expected.

library(XML)
d = xmlTree("foo", namespaces = list("url"))
d$doc()
# <?xml version="1.0"?>
# <url:foo xmlns:url="<dummy>"/>

CodePudding user response：

There seems to be a difference between nameless lists and lists with an empty name in R.

1 - A nameless list:

list("url")
# [[1]]
# [1] "url"
names(list("url"))
# NULL

2 - A named list:

list(prefix = "url")
# $prefix
# [1] "url"
names(list(prefix = "url"))
# [1] "prefix"

3 - An incorrectly initialised empty-name list:

list("" = "url")
# Error: attempt to use zero-length variable name

4 - An hacky way to initialise an empty-name list:

setNames(list(prefix = "url"), "")
# [[1]]
# [1] "url"
names(setNames(list(prefix = "url"), ""))
# [1] ""

It would seem 1. and 4. are identical, however, in the package XML they produce different results. The first gives the incorrect XML as mentioned in the OP, whereas option 4. produces:

library(XML)
d = d = xmlTree("foo", namespaces = setNames(list(prefix = "url"), ""))
d$doc() 
# <?xml version="1.0"?>
# <foo xmlns="url"/>