saving nodes created by user on JavaFX GUI-CodePudding

I made a GUI on JavaFX that's for creating timetables. when I open the app I can add plans (Buttons) to day columns (VBox). ofc the changes aren't saved after I close the app: the next time I open it the table is empty. my question is how can I make it save nodes that the user creates so the next time i open the app they're there?

this is the exact part where the nodes get added for what it's worth:

void ask_add_plan(ActionEvent event)
    {
        Button b = (Button) event.getSource();
        VBox v = (VBox) b.getParent();

        AnchorPane pop_up = new AnchorPane(); //this pop up is to specify things about the plan 
                                              //but i removed unnecessary code for simplicity
        
        VBox pop_up_v = new VBox();

        Button add = new Button("Add");
      
        add.setOnAction(e->{
            Button plan = new Button(what_to_do.getText());
           
            v.getChildren().add(plan);

            container.getChildren().remove(pop_up); //container is the anchor pane everything's in
        });

       
        pop_up_v.getChildren().add(add);

        pop_up.getChildren().add(pop_up_v);

        container.getChildren().add(pop_up); //container is the anchor pane everything's in
    }

CodePudding user response：

The JavaFX nodes are just the presentation of your data. They are not meant to be saved. Store the actual data itself in a private field in your class.

In your Application.stop method, write the data to a file.
In your Application.start method, read that file and use it to rebuild JavaFX nodes.

private static final Path PLANS_FILE =
    Path.of(System.getProperty("user.home"), "plans.txt");

private final List<String> plans = new ArrayList<>();

void ask_add_plan(ActionEvent event) {

    // ...

    add.setOnAction(e -> {
        String planText = what_to_do.getText();

        plans.add(planText);

        Button plan = new Button(planText);
        v.getChildren().add(plan);
        container.getChildren().remove(pop_up);
    });
}

@Override
public void start(Stage primaryStage)
throws Exception {

    // ...

    if (Files.exists(PLANS_FILE)) {
        plans.addAll(Files.readAllLines(PLANS_FILE));

        // Add UI elements for each stored plan.
        for (String planText : plans) {
            Button planButton = new Button(planText);
            v.getChildren().add(planButton);
            container.getChildren().remove(pop_up);
        }
    }
}

@Override
public void stop()
throws IOException {
    Files.write(PLANS_FILE, plans);
}

The above is just a simplified example. The file doesn’t have to store just strings.

I get the impression that the data created in the application is more complex than just plan strings. For complex data, XML may be more a suitable file format. Or you can use Java serialization. Or, you can invent your own file format.

You also don’t have to read from and write to a file. You can use a database, if you’re comfortable with database programming. Or you can Preferences (though Preferences are not well suited to storing lists of complex data).

CodePudding user response：

You should use MVP (model-view-presenter) pattern. Saving data in UI layer is not a good practice. Create a model with data and then serialize it.